Ambivalence, not resistance: motivational interviewing

A winding forest path between trees in morning mist.

Ambivalence and discord

Wikipedia describes motivational interviewing (MI) as a person-centered counseling approach for examining and resolving mixed feelings about a change in behavior[1]. Ambivalence involves reasons for change alongside reasons for continuing the current behavior, a tension the stages-of-change overview describes as weighing the advantages and disadvantages[2]. Wikipedia’s MI entry calls statements of desire, ability, reasons, or need for change change talk[1].

The MI entry reports that the developers abandoned resistance because a single term could obscure different aspects of ambivalence and place blame on the client[1]. It separately describes how arguments can diminish rapport and lead a person to pull away from the counselor, a form of discord in the working relationship[1]. Ambivalence describes a tension about the behavior and discord describes friction in the interaction[1].

Wikipedia’s historical discussion groups arguing, interrupting, denying, and ignoring among behaviors formerly described under the single label of resistance[1]. The entry describes autonomy in terms of the person retaining ownership of the choice to change[1].

Motivation as a practice subject

The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) describes TIP 35 as addressing methods that focus on motivation in substance use disorder treatment, with participation and retention among the aims[3]. In brief intervention, SAMHSA likewise identifies awareness of substance use and motivation for behavioral change as aims, as part of a service model that includes screening and referral[4]. Wikipedia’s overview of brief intervention identifies MI among the ways that model’s focused conversation has been approached in the United States[5].

The SAMHSA Library also describes a related motivation manual in terms of several approaches, their integration, and tools for assessing motivation[3]. The Wikipedia account of MI includes motivational enhancement therapy among its adaptations and describes that form as time-limited in a study of treatment for alcohol problems[1]. These references use motivation at different levels of specificity, from a topic across substance use services to a particular counseling approach and an adaptation of it[3][1].

The counseling stance and core skills

The MI entry describes a partnership that respects the client’s autonomy and pays attention to the reasons they identify for themselves[1]. It describes acceptance without judgment as part of the interviewer’s stance and explains the counselor’s direction in terms of a shared focus on exploring ambivalence[1]. The entry also describes readiness as something that can fluctuate during the interaction[1].

In describing the core conversation skills, Wikipedia lists open-ended questions, reflective listening, affirmation, and restating what the person has said[1]. Open questions give the person room to describe their circumstances from their own point of view[1]. The entry describes reflection as conveying the ideas the person has expressed in different words and affirmation as recognizing strengths and prior efforts[1]. The account connects recognition of strengths with self-efficacy, the person’s confidence in their capacity to change[1].

Wikipedia describes the concept of discrepancy as a difference the person recognizes between a current pattern and what they want life or behavior to be like after a change[1]. Its description treats the person’s own recognition of that difference as part of the discussion, with reflective listening as a way the counselor follows what the person has already expressed[1].

Functions of the interview

Wikipedia names engaging, focusing, evoking, and planning as functions that can occur in varying order[1]. It associates engaging with building understanding of the person’s circumstances and focusing with agreeing on a direction that matters to them[1]. Evoking concerns the person’s reasons for change, while planning concerns how the person might carry out that change and express commitment[1]. The entry calls expressions of commitment commitment talk within its description of planning, which gives that language a different emphasis from the desire, ability, reasons, and needs described as change talk[1].

The focusing description allows the initial direction to come from the person, the circumstances, or the clinician, and locates the decision about which goal to pursue in joint discussion[1]. In its account of planning, the entry describes goal characteristics such as specificity and measurability as ways to give planned change a benchmark[1].

Stages of change

Wikipedia describes the transtheoretical model as a separate framework for changes in readiness, confidence, and behavior over time[2]. The model uses precontemplation for circumstances without an intention to act, contemplation for weighing reasons for and against change, and preparation for intending to act soon and beginning to take steps[2]. It describes action as making changes in behavior and maintenance as sustaining changes and addressing the possibility of relapse[2]. The overview also lists termination for a point at which the person no longer expects to return to the prior behavior and describes relapse as a possible return to an earlier stage[2].

For the transtheoretical model, decisional balance describes how a person weighs the potential gains and costs of a change[2]. Self-efficacy in the model refers to confidence in coping in a particular situation without returning to a behavior the person is trying to change[2]. The model’s account of processes of change also includes the role of social support, commitments, and environmental cues in sustaining changed behavior[2].

The chapter distinguishes the stages named in the model from the interview functions described in MI. One vocabulary concerns readiness and behavior over time, and the other concerns the purposes that arise during a conversation[2][1].

Wikipedia’s discussion flags concerns about the reliability of assigning people to precise stages and the value of fixed times for predicting behavior[2]. The core practice chapter places motivation alongside other counseling subject areas, including the broader work of relapse prevention.

Sources used on this page

  1. Motivational interviewing - Wikipedia
  2. Transtheoretical model - Wikipedia
  3. TIP 35: Enhancing Motivation for Change in Substance Use Disorder Treatment | SAMHSA Library
  4. SBIRT: Screening, Brief Intervention, and Referral to Treatment | SAMHSA
  5. Brief intervention - Wikipedia