Ethics in the helping professions: codes, confidentiality and decisions

Professional codes and their scope
The American Counseling Association (ACA) describes its role as providing access to and interpretation of its Code of Ethics, with guidance available to members and the public[1]. The ACA identifies technology use, distance counseling, social media, confidentiality, and recordkeeping as areas addressed by the code[1]. Its overview also identifies multiculturalism and diversity, boundaries, intervention selection, and counselors’ personal values as subjects of ethical standards[1].
The ACA’s ethics page identifies adherence to the code as an expectation of membership[1]. It also describes the role of its Ethics Committee in processing allegations of code violations by active members[1].
The National Board for Certified Counselors (NBCC) applies its conduct standards to applicants and to people who hold its certifications[2]. Its ethics materials describe enforceable policies, disclosure procedures, and a process for reviewing concerns involving either group[2]. NBCC makes its Code of Ethics available to counselors and members of the public, including people trying to understand the expectations connected to the credential[2].
NBCC places professional disciplinary matters and legal matters connected to counseling practice among the subjects of its disclosures policy[2]. The board describes counseling professionals as having a role in managing its review process[2]. The handbook’s section on specialty credentials describes the certification bodies and the credentials listed in their materials.
Boundaries and overlapping roles
Boundaries concern the limits of a professional relationship. Wikipedia’s overview of boundaries in clinical mental health counseling describes physical, emotional, psychological, and social dimensions of that relationship[3]. Its entry on dual relationships uses the term for situations in which a mental health practitioner and a client have overlapping roles and identifies multiple relationships as another term in the literature[4]. The ACA places boundary questions and the possible imposition of personal values among the subjects addressed by its counseling code[1].
The ACA’s discussion of its code includes distance counseling and use of social media with clients, where the professional relationship can involve communications outside a shared office[1]. Wikipedia’s description of dual relationships distinguishes simultaneous roles from an intended future relationship or an existing relationship with someone connected to the client in its discussion of the APA’s psychology code[4]. These are categories described by that source in the context of psychology. The clinical supervision chapter describes another professional relationship with an explicit evaluative function.
Confidentiality and informed consent
Confidentiality concerns who has access to information and how it may be distributed. Wikipedia presents it as a set of restrictions that can follow from rules, promises, agreements, or laws[5].
The Wikipedia entry also uses the term in a medical context for communications exchanged during care[5]. The ACA addresses the confidential character of client information in the same code that addresses how counseling is delivered at a distance and how records are kept[1]. A conversation, the record of it, and a later release of information each involve confidentiality in a different respect, from the original expectation of limited access to questions about use or distribution[5][6].
Wikipedia’s ethics overview defines informed consent in terms of sufficient information and understanding to decide about accepting risk, including information about benefits, alternatives, and the right to decline in a treatment context[7]. The overview also identifies disclosure of medical information and participation in research as contexts for the consent principle[7].
In its discussion of decision-making capacity, the Wikipedia reference separates understanding relevant facts from appreciating how those facts apply to the person and from reasoning about them in making a choice[7]. The entry discusses why a statement of agreement alone may say little about the person’s understanding of the implications[7].
Federal rules on substance use disorder records
The electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR) describes 42 CFR Part 2 as restricting use and disclosure of substance use disorder patient records maintained in connection with a program covered by Part 2[6]. Its stated purpose is to avoid making a person more vulnerable because a record exists of their seeking substance use disorder treatment[6].
The eCFR organizes Part 2 into general provisions and provisions for uses and disclosures with consent, uses and disclosures without consent, and uses and disclosures authorized through court orders[6]. Its table of contents distinguishes safeguards and security from subjects such as access, notice, accounting of disclosures, and requests for privacy protection[6].
The eCFR distinguishes a permitted use or disclosure from one the regulation compels, describing a permission as lifting a restriction in defined circumstances[6]. It identifies compliance investigations by the Secretary in its separate discussion of required disclosure[6]. The purpose statement locates the regulation’s role in protecting records, with treatment, research, and evaluation named as substantive functions outside its direction[6].
In the eCFR’s organization, patient consent and the use made of the information are distinct subjects. The provisions dealing with consent include the consent form and rules for use or disclosure given written consent[6]. Provisions under a separate heading address use and disclosure without consent and identify research, evaluation, and public health among the subjects they cover[6]. Another part of the rule addresses orders authorizing use and disclosure and the scope of those orders[6].
The eCFR describes a protective purpose for the records rules. It says the provisions are intended to prevent access to a substance use disorder record from placing a person who seeks treatment through a Part 2 program in a more vulnerable position than a person who does not seek treatment[6]. The purpose provision differentiates safeguards on information from the conduct of treatment, research, or evaluation[6].
How Part 2 refers to HIPAA
Wikipedia’s HIPAA reference uses protected health information for information associated with health status, the provision of care, or payment that can be linked to an individual and is held by a covered entity[8]. The eCFR’s description of Part 2 states that Part 2 does not limit a patient’s right under the referenced provisions to request a restriction on the use or disclosure of a record for purposes of treatment, payment, or health care operations[6]. It similarly refers to a covered entity’s choice to obtain the patient’s consent for a use or disclosure to carry out treatment, payment, or health care operations[6]. Its enforcement provision identifies a set of federal enforcement procedures that also applies to covered entities and business associates under the cited HIPAA rules[6]. The eCFR also describes a route for a Part 2 complaint that parallels complaints under the administrative simplification provisions of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)[6].
The HIPAA reference describes categories of covered entities, including certain healthcare providers, health plans, and clearinghouses[8]. The Part 2 purpose provision instead describes records maintained in connection with a covered program[6]. The source descriptions begin at different points: the status of the entity in the Privacy Rule description and the connection between the record and the program in the Part 2 description[8][6].
Ethical decision-making references
The ACA describes an ethics desk reference for counselors and students that brings together a decision-making model, material organized around the code’s standards, and a list of ethics resources[9]. The ACA’s separate ethics resource page identifies consultation and complaints as different functions alongside access to the code itself[1].
Within the ACA’s ethics materials, the description of the decision-making model concerns applying professional standards, including in activities outside a counseling session[9]. A code and a federal regulation therefore answer different questions about the same professional subject, as illustrated by the ACA’s inclusion of confidentiality among its ethical standards and the eCFR’s focus on defined records and programs[1][6].
Sources used on this page
- Counseling Ethics & ACA Code of Ethics Resources | ACA
- Ethics | NBCC
- Professional boundaries - Wikipedia
- Dual relationship - Wikipedia
- Confidentiality - Wikipedia
- eCFR :: 42 CFR Part 2 -- Confidentiality of Substance Use Disorder Patient Records
- Informed consent - Wikipedia
- Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Wikipedia
- Ethics Desk Reference for Counselors, 2nd Edition